This is my holy grail eyeliner. The texture is very creamy and super easy to apply and it doesn't smudge. The black is jet black and glides really comfortably on my waterline without it transfering to my undereye are, it even stayes on the corner of my eyes even when  my eyes tend to water alot when it's windy or bright.

The Pink topaz is gorgeous on my aegyo sal and really compliments my pale skintone, it also never greases on the fine lines around my eyes and stays put the whole day!